Skip to content

Cannot seem to get correct results for Connected Components #408

@altanh

Description

@altanh

Hi, I've been trying to run the connected components application provided by Galois (both local CPU and distributed CPU) and cannot seem to get correct results unless I use the Serial implementation.

I ran the standard CMake setup using the release-6.0 branch, with a few small hiccups

  • Had to add #include <optional> in graph-convert
  • Additionally, got an error about a constexpr in lonestar/scientific/cpu/longestedge/test/catch.hpp:10735:58 which I hacked around since I don't think it should affect anything else

CMAKE Command: cmake -S . -B _build/ -DCMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=Release -DGALOIS_ENABLE_DIST=1 -DMPI_EXECUTABLE_SUFFIX=".mpich"

Commands I ran

  • _build/lonestar/analytics/cpu/connected-components/connected-components-cpu --algo=Serial --symmetricGraph rand_cc_5.gr

    • correctly reports 5
  • _build/lonestar/analytics/cpu/connected-components/connected-components-cpu --algo=Sync --symmetricGraph rand_cc_5.gr

    • reports 100 and crashes at verifying, doesn't matter how many threads I use
  • _build/lonestar/analytics/distributed/connected-components/connected-components-push-dist --symmetricGraph inputs/rand_cc_5.gr

    • reports 100
	  D-Galois Benchmark Suite v6.0.0 (unknown)
	  Copyright (C) 2018 The University of Texas at Austin
	  http://iss.ices.utexas.edu/galois/
	  
	  application: ConnectedComp - Distributed Heterogeneous with filter.
	  ConnectedComp on Distributed Galois.
	  
	  [0] Master distribution time : 6e-06 seconds to read 56 bytes in 6 seeks (9.33333 MBPS)
	  [0] Starting graph reading.
	  [0] Reading graph complete.
	  [0] Edge inspection time: 1.1e-05 seconds to read 3392 bytes (308.364 MBPS)
	  Loading edge-data while creating edges
	  [0] Edge loading time: 2e-06 seconds to read 3392 bytes (1696 MBPS)
	  [0] Graph construction complete.
	  [0] InitializeGraph::go called
	  [0] ConnectedComp::go run 0 called
	  Number of components is 100
	  [0] ConnectedComp::go run 1 called
	  Number of components is 100
	  [0] ConnectedComp::go run 2 called
	  Number of components is 100
	  STAT_TYPE, HOST_ID, REGION, CATEGORY, TOTAL_TYPE, TOTAL
	  STAT, 0, dGraph_Generic, CuSPStateRounds, HOST_0, 100
	  STAT, 0, Gluon, ReduceNumMessages_ConnectedComp_0, HSUM, 0
	  STAT, 0, Gluon, ReduceNumMessages_ConnectedComp_1, HSUM, 0
	  STAT, 0, Gluon, ReduceNumMessages_ConnectedComp_2, HSUM, 0
	  STAT, 0, ConnectedComp, NumWorkItems_0, HSUM, 100
	  STAT, 0, ConnectedComp, NumIterations_0, HMAX, 3
	  STAT, 0, ConnectedComp, NumWorkItems_1, HSUM, 100
	  STAT, 0, ConnectedComp, NumIterations_1, HMAX, 3
	  STAT, 0, ConnectedComp, NumWorkItems_2, HSUM, 100
	  STAT, 0, ConnectedComp, NumIterations_2, HMAX, 3
	  STAT, 0, Gluon, ReplicationFactor, HOST_0, 1
	  PARAM, 0, DistBench, CommandLine, HOST_0, _build/lonestar/analytics/distributed/connected-components/connected-components-push-dist --symmetricGraph ../../inputs/rand_cc_5.gr
	  PARAM, 0, DistBench, Threads, HOST_0, 1
	  PARAM, 0, DistBench, Hosts, HOST_0, 1
	  PARAM, 0, DistBench, Runs, HOST_0, 3
	  PARAM, 0, DistBench, Run_UUID, HOST_0, acc9e1df-4dc8-49e1-9b04-59a390ce0c1c
	  PARAM, 0, DistBench, Input, HOST_0, ../../inputs/rand_cc_5.gr
	  PARAM, 0, DistBench, PartitionScheme, HOST_0, oec
	  PARAM, 0, DistBench, Hostname, HOST_0, redpoint
	  PARAM, 0, ConnectedComp, Max Iterations, HOST_0, 1000
	  PARAM, 0, dGraph, GenericPartitioner, HOST_0, 0

Any help would be greatly appreciated. I have attached the input files (both .mtx and .gr formats). Note that I have locally verified the correctness of the graph format conversion by round-tripping then running a simple isomorphism check. I've tried a few graphs with no success so I doubt the specific input matters.

I am happy to provide any system information or build output as needed, thanks!
rand_cc_5.zip

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type
    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions