Summary
Write unit tests for the pure functions that check, compare, and build Kubernetes status conditions. These are critical to the controller's decision-making and are all testable without envtest.
Testing Guidance
For each function, think about:
- What does it return for normal, expected input?
- What happens at the boundaries — nil conditions, empty slices, missing fields?
- If there's branching logic, have you covered each branch?
Scope
api/v1alpha1/apikey_types.go
IsApproved() — checks whether an APIKey has an "Approved" condition set to True. Consider: condition present and True, condition present and False, no conditions at all, nil status.
internal/controller/apiproduct_helper.go
IsAuthPolicyAcceptedAndEnforced() — returns true only when both Accepted and Enforced conditions are True. Think about each combination: both true, one true, neither, nil policy.
IsAuthPolicyAccepted(), IsAuthPolicyEnforced() — individual condition checks.
IsAuthPolicyConditionTrue() — generic condition checker. Handles nil policy — test that path.
internal/controller/apiproduct_controller.go
authPolicyDiscoveredCondition() — builds a condition reflecting whether an AuthPolicy was found and is accepted+enforced. Test with nil policy, found but not enforced, and fully healthy.
openAPISpecReadyCondition() — builds a condition for OpenAPI spec readiness. Has three paths: no URL configured (returns nil), fetch error, and success.
oidcDiscoveredCondition() — builds a condition for OIDC discovery. Has three paths: no auth scheme, fetch error, and success.
internal/controller/apikey_status_controller.go
getInvalidReason() — returns a reason string from a condition, or a default if nil. Simple null-safe getter.
internal/controller/apikeyrequest_status_controller.go
conditionsEqual() — compares two condition slices ignoring LastTransitionTime. Think about: same conditions, different order, different status, empty slices, nil.
copyConditions() — deep copies a condition slice. Verify the copy is independent of the original (mutating the copy shouldn't affect the source).
Review & Verification
PRs should include:
- How to review the changes (areas of interest, suggested review order)
- Steps to confirm locally:
make test runs and passes
Summary
Write unit tests for the pure functions that check, compare, and build Kubernetes status conditions. These are critical to the controller's decision-making and are all testable without envtest.
Testing Guidance
For each function, think about:
Scope
api/v1alpha1/apikey_types.goIsApproved()— checks whether an APIKey has an "Approved" condition set to True. Consider: condition present and True, condition present and False, no conditions at all, nil status.internal/controller/apiproduct_helper.goIsAuthPolicyAcceptedAndEnforced()— returns true only when both Accepted and Enforced conditions are True. Think about each combination: both true, one true, neither, nil policy.IsAuthPolicyAccepted(),IsAuthPolicyEnforced()— individual condition checks.IsAuthPolicyConditionTrue()— generic condition checker. Handles nil policy — test that path.internal/controller/apiproduct_controller.goauthPolicyDiscoveredCondition()— builds a condition reflecting whether an AuthPolicy was found and is accepted+enforced. Test with nil policy, found but not enforced, and fully healthy.openAPISpecReadyCondition()— builds a condition for OpenAPI spec readiness. Has three paths: no URL configured (returns nil), fetch error, and success.oidcDiscoveredCondition()— builds a condition for OIDC discovery. Has three paths: no auth scheme, fetch error, and success.internal/controller/apikey_status_controller.gogetInvalidReason()— returns a reason string from a condition, or a default if nil. Simple null-safe getter.internal/controller/apikeyrequest_status_controller.goconditionsEqual()— compares two condition slices ignoringLastTransitionTime. Think about: same conditions, different order, different status, empty slices, nil.copyConditions()— deep copies a condition slice. Verify the copy is independent of the original (mutating the copy shouldn't affect the source).Review & Verification
PRs should include:
make testruns and passes