Skip to content

Feature Request: Implement Yang et al. 2024 SIDM Profile as Default for Subhalos and LOS Halos #631

Description

@mwiet

Description

Implementation of a single closed-form parametric profile from Yang, Nadler, Yu & Zhong (2024) that spans the entire gravothermal sequence. This should become the default SIDM cored/core-collapsed path for lens-plane subhalos and line-of-sight (LOS) halos, moving the existing Kaplinghat profile to a legacy status.

Proposed Implementation Details

  1. Profile Hierarchy & Default Status:

    • Default: Make the Yang+ 2024 profile the primary, default SIDM path for modeling.
    • Legacy: Retain the Kaplinghat framework strictly as a legacy option for backward compatibility.
  2. Physical Collapse-Time Solve (τ formulation):

    • Implement the per-halo dimensionless evolution time τ = t / t_c.
    • Calculate the collapse time t_c from the physical parameters at the halo's CDM baseline (ρ_s, r_s):
      t_c = (150 / C) / [ (σ_eff / m) * ρ_s * r_s * √(4πG * ρ_s) ]
      (where C = 0.75).
    • Use a per-plane t_age to compute t (so τ updates properly dynamically depending on the redshift plane of the halo/subhalo).
  3. Velocity Dependence (Outmezguine+ 2023):

    • Velocity dependence is explicitly in scope.
    • σ_eff must be computed dynamically using a velocity-dependent cross-section: σ ∝ v^{-a}, parameterized by a (following Outmezguine+ 2023).

References

To assist with the implementation and physical constants, refer to the following literature:

  • Yang+ 2024 (arXiv:2305.16176): The primary profile parameterization, including τ and t_c formulations.
  • Rocha+ 2013 (arXiv:1208.3025): Core baseline SIDM scaling properties.
  • Outmezguine+ 2023 (arXiv:2204.06568): Universal gravothermal sequence and the formulation for σ_eff / velocity dependence.
  • Phoroutan-Mehr & Yu 2025 (arXiv:2411.18751): Advanced implementation of σ ∝ v^{-a} (includes an optional spike feature, which should be off by default).
  • Yang+ 2025 (arXiv:2406.10753): Validation of the gravothermal profile.
  • Raut+ 2026 (arXiv:2604.22013): Extended τ-model (should be integrated as an optional plug-in).
  • Ando+ 2024 (arXiv:2403.16633): Population τ mapping used for the diagnostic f_cc cross-check.
  • Minor+ 2021 / SHARP IX 2025 (arXiv:2011.10627 / arXiv:2505.07944): The J0946 collapse target data for integration tests and empirical validation.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions