Skip to content

[Request] Highlight text without attaching a comment #52

Description

@simon1561

Thanks for this plugin — the inline storage format is exactly what I was
looking for. I use Obsidian for investment research notes, and being able to
read the comments back out of the raw Markdown with other tooling is the
reason I picked it over the alternatives.

One gap for my workflow: while reading a long document I mark passages that
matter without having anything to say about them yet. Right now a highlight
only exists as a side effect of a comment, so marking a passage means creating
an empty or placeholder comment thread, which then shows up as a card in the
margin and in "All discussions".

Is a comment-free highlight something you've considered, or is it deliberately
out of scope for the plugin?

I don't want to push a particular design on you, but one shape that seems
consistent with the existing format would be a body block with no thread lines
— the anchor markers stay as they are, so nothing changes for tools reading the
file, and such a comment could render as a plain highlight with no card. Happy
to be told a different approach fits better, or that this belongs in a separate
highlighting plugin.

Either way, thanks for the clear format reference and the validation script —
they made it easy to evaluate the plugin before installing it.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    Status
    Completed

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions