Skip to content

Commit 9ec564a

Browse files
max-cxmax-cx
committed
OBSDOCS-1605: IBM Cloud Object Storage to the ref table snippet
1 parent 5b67458 commit 9ec564a

File tree

3 files changed

+192
-1
lines changed

3 files changed

+192
-1
lines changed

‎modules/distr-tracing-tempo-object-storage-setup-ibm-storage.adoc‎

Lines changed: 1 addition & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ $ ibmcloud resource service-key-create <tempo_bucket> Writer \
3737
[source,terminal]
3838
----
3939
$ oc -n <namespace> create secret generic <ibm_cos_secret> \
40-
--from-literal=bucket="<tempo_bucket>" \
40+
--from-literal=bucket="<ibm_bucket_name>" \
4141
--from-literal=endpoint="<ibm_bucket_endpoint>" \
4242
--from-literal=access_key_id="<ibm_bucket_access_key>" \
4343
--from-literal=access_key_secret="<ibm_bucket_secret_key>"

‎reports/PR-103700-review-assessment.md‎

Lines changed: 181 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,181 @@
1+
# OpenShift Documentation PR Review Assessment
2+
3+
**PR Number:** [#103700](https://github.com/openshift/openshift-docs/pull/103700)
4+
**JIRA Issue:** [OBSDOCS-1605](https://issues.redhat.com/browse/OBSDOCS-1605)
5+
**Author:** max-cx
6+
**Review Date:** December 10, 2025
7+
**Reviewer:** Automated Review System
8+
9+
---
10+
11+
## Executive Summary
12+
13+
**Overall Recommendation:** ✅ **APPROVE**
14+
15+
This PR adds IBM Cloud Object Storage configuration details to the distributed tracing Tempo reference table. The change is minimal, well-structured, and passes all technical requirements. The PR is ready to merge.
16+
17+
**Estimated Fix Time:** 0 minutes (no fixes required)
18+
19+
---
20+
21+
## Complete Criteria Checklist
22+
23+
| # | Criteria | Status | Details |
24+
|---|----------|--------|---------|
25+
| 1 | Verify PR has only 1 commit | ✅ PASS | Single commit: `e4ace9a24dd5c8d76bc5776a2d00625aa179ec16` |
26+
| 2 | Verify PR has QE approval, if required | ✅ PASS | QE approval confirmed in PR description (checkbox marked) |
27+
| 3 | Must have an empty line between H1 heading and first paragraph | ✅ PASS | File is a snippet with table content only, no H1 heading present |
28+
| 4 | Must be an empty line between include statements | ✅ PASS | No include statements in this file |
29+
| 5 | No H3 headings (===) in any files | ✅ PASS | No H3 headings found |
30+
| 6 | No additional text surrounding links in additional resources sections | ✅ PASS | No additional resources section present |
31+
| 7 | No floating .Headings unless above example/table/figure | ✅ PASS | ID anchor is properly associated with table element |
32+
| 8 | Modules must follow concept/procedure/reference format | ✅ PASS | This is a SNIPPET, not a module |
33+
| 9 | All modules and assemblies include one H1 and short description | ✅ PASS | This is a SNIPPET with proper content type declaration |
34+
| 10 | All files follow mod docs templates | ✅ PASS | Snippet includes `:_mod-docs-content-type: SNIPPET` |
35+
| 11 | All conversations must be resolved | ✅ PASS | No unresolved review threads |
36+
| 12 | Procedure modules strictly follow template | ✅ PASS | Not applicable (this is a snippet, not a procedure) |
37+
| 13 | Scan preview for proper rendering | ✅ PASS | All elements render correctly |
38+
| 14 | Scan text for obvious typos or poor wording | ✅ PASS | No typos or wording issues detected |
39+
| 15 | Verify that all links work | ✅ PASS | No new external links added |
40+
| 16 | Check that there are no xrefs in modules | ✅ PASS | No xrefs present in snippet |
41+
| 17 | Check that xrefs use proper syntax | ✅ PASS | No xrefs to validate |
42+
| 18 | Check headings contain only alphanumeric and spaces | ✅ PASS | Table heading follows conventions |
43+
| 19 | Check all system tests have passed | ✅ PASS | openshift-ci bot confirms "all tests passed!" |
44+
45+
---
46+
47+
## File-by-File Analysis
48+
49+
### snippets/distr-tracing-tempo-required-secret-parameters.adoc
50+
51+
**File Type:** SNIPPET
52+
**Lines Changed:** +10 additions, 0 deletions
53+
**Status:** ✅ PASS
54+
55+
#### Structure Analysis
56+
- ✅ Proper content type declaration: `:_mod-docs-content-type: SNIPPET`
57+
- ✅ Proper ID anchor: `[id="required_secret_parameters_{context}"]`
58+
- ✅ Well-formed AsciiDoc table with header row
59+
- ✅ Consistent formatting with existing entries
60+
61+
#### Content Added
62+
The PR adds a new table row for IBM Cloud Object Storage with the following parameters:
63+
```
64+
|{ibm-cloud-object-storage}
65+
|
66+
`bucket: <tempo_bucket>`
67+
68+
`endpoint: <ibm_bucket_endpoint>`
69+
70+
`access_key_id: <ibm_bucket_access_key>`
71+
72+
`access_key_secret: <ibm_bucket_secret_key>`
73+
```
74+
75+
#### Quality Assessment
76+
- ✅ Consistent with existing table entries (MinIO, Amazon S3, Azure, GCP)
77+
- ✅ Uses proper AsciiDoc attribute for IBM Cloud Object Storage name
78+
- ✅ Parameter names follow established naming conventions
79+
- ✅ Placeholder values use appropriate angle bracket notation
80+
- ✅ No unnecessary comments or documentation links (appropriate for this storage provider)
81+
82+
#### Technical Validation
83+
- ✅ Table syntax is correct (proper cell delimiters)
84+
- ✅ No markdown formatting issues
85+
- ✅ Backticks properly used for inline code
86+
- ✅ Line breaks appropriately placed for readability
87+
88+
---
89+
90+
## Content Quality Assessment
91+
92+
### Accuracy
93+
- Content copied from published OCP 4.18 documentation
94+
- Technical parameters are standard for IBM Cloud Object Storage authentication
95+
- Consistent with industry-standard S3-compatible storage configuration
96+
97+
### Completeness
98+
- All required secret parameters for IBM Cloud Object Storage are included
99+
- Parameter set is appropriate and sufficient for Tempo integration
100+
- No missing critical configuration values
101+
102+
### Consistency
103+
- Formatting matches existing table entries
104+
- Parameter naming conventions align with other storage providers
105+
- Uses established documentation patterns
106+
107+
### Clarity
108+
- Parameter names are self-explanatory
109+
- Placeholder names clearly indicate their purpose
110+
- No ambiguous or confusing content
111+
112+
---
113+
114+
## CI/CD Validation
115+
116+
### Test Results
117+
- ✅ **ci/prow/validate-asciidoc**: SUCCESS
118+
- ✅ **ci/prow/validate-portal**: SUCCESS
119+
- ✅ **Overall Test Status**: All tests passed
120+
121+
### Build Status
122+
- Preview build completed successfully
123+
- Preview URL: [View Preview](https://103700--ocpdocs-pr.netlify.app/openshift-enterprise/latest/observability/distr_tracing/distr-tracing-tempo-installing#distr-tracing-tempo-object-storage-setup_distr-tracing-tempo-installing)
124+
125+
---
126+
127+
## Review Status
128+
129+
### Approvals
130+
- ✅ **Peer Review**: Approved by IshwarKanse (MEMBER) on 2025-12-10 at 05:50:32 UTC
131+
- ✅ **QE Review**: Approved (confirmed in PR description)
132+
133+
### Conversations
134+
- No review threads present
135+
- No unresolved conversations
136+
- No pending feedback
137+
138+
---
139+
140+
## Issues Found
141+
142+
**None.** This PR meets all documentation standards and requirements.
143+
144+
---
145+
146+
## Recommendations
147+
148+
### Immediate Actions
149+
1. ✅ **Merge PR** - All criteria met, no blockers present
150+
151+
### Future Considerations
152+
None. This is a straightforward addition with no architectural or process concerns.
153+
154+
---
155+
156+
## Additional Notes
157+
158+
### Context
159+
This PR addresses OBSDOCS-1605 by adding IBM Cloud Object Storage configuration details to the Tempo distributed tracing documentation. The content was sourced from the published OCP 4.18 documentation and applies to versions 4.12-4.21.
160+
161+
### Scope
162+
The change is minimal and focused:
163+
- Single file modified (snippet)
164+
- Only additive changes (no deletions)
165+
- No impact on other documentation files
166+
- Self-contained table entry
167+
168+
### Risk Assessment
169+
**Risk Level:** Very Low
170+
- Minor documentation enhancement
171+
- No code changes
172+
- No breaking changes to existing content
173+
- Isolated to single snippet file
174+
175+
---
176+
177+
## Summary
178+
179+
This PR successfully adds IBM Cloud Object Storage support documentation to the Tempo object storage reference table. All 19 review criteria have been satisfied, CI tests pass, and the content quality is high. The PR has received appropriate approvals and is ready for merge.
180+
181+
**Final Recommendation:** ✅ **APPROVE AND MERGE**

‎snippets/distr-tracing-tempo-required-secret-parameters.adoc‎

Lines changed: 10 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -39,6 +39,16 @@ See link:https://operator.min.io/[MinIO Operator].
3939

4040
`access_key_secret: <minio_access_key_secret>`
4141

42+
|{ibm-cloud-object-storage}
43+
|
44+
`bucket: <ibm_bucket_name>`
45+
46+
`endpoint: <ibm_bucket_endpoint>`
47+
48+
`access_key_id: <ibm_bucket_access_key>`
49+
50+
`access_key_secret: <ibm_bucket_secret_key>`
51+
4252
|Amazon S3
4353
|
4454
`name: tempostack-dev-s3 # example`

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)