A note for the community
- Please vote on this issue by adding a 👍 reaction to the original issue to help the community and maintainers prioritize this request
- If you are interested in working on this issue or have submitted a pull request, please leave a comment
Problem
Summary
The Debian package appears to have two packaging issues:
/etc/vector/vector.yaml is not marked as a Debian conffile, causing locally modified configurations to be overwritten during upgrades.
- Example configuration files are installed under
/etc/vector/examples/ and marked as conffiles, even though they appear to be documentation rather than administrator-managed configuration.
Version
- Vector: 0.57.0-1
- Installation method: Official
.deb package
- Distribution: Ubuntu
- Upgrade performed with:
Issue 1: /etc/vector/vector.yaml is not a conffile
During an upgrade, my locally modified /etc/vector/vector.yaml was overwritten.
Inspecting the package metadata shows that vector.yaml is not listed as a Debian conffile:
$ cat control/conffiles
/etc/default/vector
/etc/vector/examples/docs_example.yaml
/etc/vector/examples/environment_variables.yaml
/etc/vector/examples/es_s3_hybrid.yaml
/etc/vector/examples/file_to_cloudwatch_metrics.yaml
/etc/vector/examples/file_to_prometheus.yaml
/etc/vector/examples/http_sink_custom_retry.yaml
/etc/vector/examples/prometheus_to_console.yaml
/etc/vector/examples/stdio.yaml
/etc/vector/examples/varint_framing_protobuf.yaml
/etc/vector/examples/wrapped_json.yaml
Since /etc/vector/vector.yaml is absent from DEBIAN/conffiles, dpkg treats it as a regular packaged file and replaces it during upgrades instead of preserving local modifications.
I believe this is a regression related to #18718.
Issue 2: Example configuration files under /etc
The package installs example configurations under /etc/vector/examples/ and marks them as conffiles.
From a Debian packaging perspective, these files seem more appropriate under a location such as:
/usr/share/doc/vector/examples/, or
/usr/share/vector/examples/
The /etc hierarchy is intended for host-specific administrator-managed configuration, while example files are static documentation/resources.
Currently the package preserves the example configuration files as conffiles but does not preserve the primary configuration file (/etc/vector/vector.yaml), which seems backwards.
Expected behavior
/etc/vector/vector.yaml should be listed as a Debian conffile so local modifications are preserved across upgrades.
- Example configuration files should be installed under
/usr/share/doc/vector/examples/ (or another appropriate location under /usr/share) instead of /etc, unless there is a specific reason for treating them as administrator-managed configuration.
Configuration
Version
0.57.0-1
Debug Output
Example Data
No response
Additional Context
No response
References
No response
A note for the community
Problem
Summary
The Debian package appears to have two packaging issues:
/etc/vector/vector.yamlis not marked as a Debian conffile, causing locally modified configurations to be overwritten during upgrades./etc/vector/examples/and marked as conffiles, even though they appear to be documentation rather than administrator-managed configuration.Version
.debpackageIssue 1:
/etc/vector/vector.yamlis not a conffileDuring an upgrade, my locally modified
/etc/vector/vector.yamlwas overwritten.Inspecting the package metadata shows that
vector.yamlis not listed as a Debian conffile:Since
/etc/vector/vector.yamlis absent fromDEBIAN/conffiles,dpkgtreats it as a regular packaged file and replaces it during upgrades instead of preserving local modifications.I believe this is a regression related to #18718.
Issue 2: Example configuration files under
/etcThe package installs example configurations under
/etc/vector/examples/and marks them as conffiles.From a Debian packaging perspective, these files seem more appropriate under a location such as:
/usr/share/doc/vector/examples/, or/usr/share/vector/examples/The
/etchierarchy is intended for host-specific administrator-managed configuration, while example files are static documentation/resources.Currently the package preserves the example configuration files as conffiles but does not preserve the primary configuration file (
/etc/vector/vector.yaml), which seems backwards.Expected behavior
/etc/vector/vector.yamlshould be listed as a Debian conffile so local modifications are preserved across upgrades./usr/share/doc/vector/examples/(or another appropriate location under/usr/share) instead of/etc, unless there is a specific reason for treating them as administrator-managed configuration.Configuration
Version
0.57.0-1
Debug Output
Example Data
No response
Additional Context
No response
References
No response