[AIT-280] Apply LiveObjects operations on ACK by lawrence-forooghian · Pull Request #419 · ably/specification

lawrence-forooghian · 2026-01-23T14:17:54Z

Written by Claude based on LODR-054. JS implementation in ably/ably-js#2155.

There are a couple of places here where I'd appreciate input from reviewers; please see the unresolved comments towards the end of the PR.

textile/objects-features.textile

Based on [1] at c3a4917. Implementation and tests are Claude-generated from the spec; I've largely resisted the temptation to tweak things that aren't quite how I'd write them but which are still correct. The only behaviour here that's not in the spec is to also apply-on-ACK for batch operations (the batch API isn't in the spec yet). [1] ably/specification#419

Based on [1] at c3a4917. Implementation and tests are Claude-generated from the spec; I've largely resisted the temptation to tweak things that aren't quite how I'd write them but which are still correct. The only behaviour here that's not in the spec is to also apply-on-ACK for batch operations (the batch API isn't in the spec yet). TODO: - test for batch [1] ably/specification#419

TODO remove testing plan Based on [1] at d809334. Implementation and tests are Claude-generated from the spec; I've reviewed them and given plenty of feedback, but largely resisted the temptation to tweak things that aren't quite how I'd write them but which are still correct. The only behaviour here that's not in the spec is to also apply-on-ACK for batch operations (the batch API isn't in the spec yet). Summary of decisions re modifications to existing tests (written by Claude): - Removed redundant `waitFor*` calls after SDK operations (`map.set()`, `counter.increment()`, etc.) - with apply-on-ACK, values are available immediately after the operation promise resolves - Kept `waitFor*` calls after REST operations (`objectsHelper.operationRequest()`, `objectsHelper.createAndSetOnMap()`) - these still require waiting for the echo to arrive over Realtime - Added explanatory comment to `applyOperationsScenarios` noting that those tests cover operations received over Realtime (via REST), and pointing to the new "Apply on ACK" section for tests of locally-applied operations [1] ably/specification#419

This reflects the functionality implemented in [1], based on the DR [2] and spec [3]. Written by Claude. [1] ably/ably-js#2155 [2] https://ably.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/LOB/pages/4671832082/LODR-054+SDK+apply+operations+on+ACK) [3] ably/specification#419

TODO remove testing plan Based on [1] at d809334. Implementation and tests are Claude-generated from the spec; I've reviewed them and given plenty of feedback, but largely resisted the temptation to tweak things that aren't quite how I'd write them but which are still correct. The only behaviour here that's not in the spec is to also apply-on-ACK for batch operations (the batch API isn't in the spec yet). Summary of decisions re modifications to existing tests (written by Claude): - Removed redundant `waitFor*` calls after SDK operations (`map.set()`, `counter.increment()`, etc.) - with apply-on-ACK, values are available immediately after the operation promise resolves - Kept `waitFor*` calls after REST operations (`objectsHelper.operationRequest()`, `objectsHelper.createAndSetOnMap()`) - these still require waiting for the echo to arrive over Realtime - Added explanatory comment to `applyOperationsScenarios` noting that those tests cover operations received over Realtime (via REST), and pointing to the new "Apply on ACK" section for tests of locally-applied operations [1] ably/specification#419

This reflects the functionality implemented in [1], based on the DR [2] and spec [3]. Written by Claude. [1] ably/ably-js#2155 [2] https://ably.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/LOB/pages/4671832082/LODR-054+SDK+apply+operations+on+ACK) [3] ably/specification#419

TODO remove testing plan Based on [1] at d809334. Implementation and tests are Claude-generated from the spec; I've reviewed them and given plenty of feedback, but largely resisted the temptation to tweak things that aren't quite how I'd write them but which are still correct. The only behaviour here that's not in the spec is to also apply-on-ACK for batch operations (the batch API isn't in the spec yet). Summary of decisions re modifications to existing tests (written by Claude): - Removed redundant `waitFor*` calls after SDK operations (`map.set()`, `counter.increment()`, etc.) - with apply-on-ACK, values are available immediately after the operation promise resolves - Kept `waitFor*` calls after REST operations (`objectsHelper.operationRequest()`, `objectsHelper.createAndSetOnMap()`) - these still require waiting for the echo to arrive over Realtime - Added explanatory comment to `applyOperationsScenarios` noting that those tests cover operations received over Realtime (via REST), and pointing to the new "Apply on ACK" section for tests of locally-applied operations [1] ably/specification#419

This reflects the functionality implemented in [1], based on the DR [2] and spec [3]. Written by Claude. [1] ably/ably-js#2155 [2] https://ably.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/LOB/pages/4671832082/LODR-054+SDK+apply+operations+on+ACK) [3] ably/specification#419

Based on [1] at d809334. Implementation and tests are Claude-generated from the spec; I've reviewed them and given plenty of feedback, but largely resisted the temptation to tweak things that aren't quite how I'd write them but which are still correct. The only behaviour here that's not in the spec is to also apply-on-ACK for batch operations (the batch API isn't in the spec yet). Summary of decisions re modifications to existing tests (written by Claude): - Removed redundant `waitFor*` calls after SDK operations (`map.set()`, `counter.increment()`, etc.) - with apply-on-ACK, values are available immediately after the operation promise resolves - Kept `waitFor*` calls after REST operations (`objectsHelper.operationRequest()`, `objectsHelper.createAndSetOnMap()`) - these still require waiting for the echo to arrive over Realtime - Added explanatory comment to `applyOperationsScenarios` noting that those tests cover operations received over Realtime (via REST), and pointing to the new "Apply on ACK" section for tests of locally-applied operations [1] ably/specification#419

lawrence-forooghian · 2026-01-30T17:13:13Z

textile/objects-features.textile

+** @(RTO20a)@ Expects the following arguments:
+*** @(RTO20a1)@ @ObjectMessage[]@ - an array of @ObjectMessage@ to be published on a channel
+** @(RTO20b)@ Calls @RealtimeObjects#publish@ ("RTO15":#RTO15) with the provided @ObjectMessage[]@ and awaits the @PublishResult@. If @publish@ fails, rethrow the error and do not proceed
+** @(RTO20c)@ If @siteCode@ is not available from "CD2j":../features#CD2j @ConnectionDetails.siteCode@, the client library must throw an @ErrorInfo@ error with @statusCode@ 400 and @code@ 40000


To reviewers: any thoughts on the most appropriate error code for this and RTO20d1?

lawrence-forooghian · 2026-01-30T17:15:20Z

textile/objects-features.textile

+**** @(RTO20d2b)@ @ObjectMessage.siteCode@ to the "CD2j":../features#CD2j @ConnectionDetails.siteCode@
+*** @(RTO20d3)@ Add the synthetic @ObjectMessage@ to the list
+** @(RTO20e)@ If the "RTO17":#RTO17 sync state is not @SYNCED@:
+*** @(RTO20e1)@ Add an entry to the @bufferedAcks@ list ("RTO7c":#RTO7c) containing the list of synthetic @ObjectMessages@ and a platform-specific signal object


To reviewers: After writing this and doing the JS implementation, I wondered whether we really need this bufferedAcks list (and even more so whether we need to specify it). We could instead just say that if if the state isn't SYNCED, to wait until it becomes SYNCED before proceeding to the application of the operation (similarly to waiting to become SYNCED before returning from .getRoot() in RTO1c). Wanted to check people would prefer this before I change it.

Written by Claude based on LODR-054 [1]. [1] https://ably.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/LOB/pages/4671832082/LODR-054+SDK+apply+operations+on+ACK

This reflects the functionality implemented in [1], based on the DR [2] and spec [3]. Written by Claude. [1] ably/ably-js#2155 [2] https://ably.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/LOB/pages/4671832082/LODR-054+SDK+apply+operations+on+ACK) [3] ably/specification#419

github-actions bot temporarily deployed to staging/pull/419 January 23, 2026 14:18 Inactive

lawrence-forooghian changed the base branch from main to clarify-BufferedObjectsOperations-scope January 23, 2026 14:18

lawrence-forooghian force-pushed the AIT-280-LiveObjects-apply-on-ACK branch from f54eee0 to 09a0dad Compare January 23, 2026 14:21

github-actions bot temporarily deployed to staging/pull/419 January 23, 2026 14:21 Inactive

Base automatically changed from clarify-BufferedObjectsOperations-scope to main January 23, 2026 14:24

lawrence-forooghian commented Jan 23, 2026

View reviewed changes