Skip to content

Conversation

@wezell
Copy link
Contributor

@wezell wezell commented Jun 24, 2025

Bug Fixes Summary for DotCMS .NET SDK

Fixed Bugs

1. ✅ Unused Variable in DotCmsUVEController

  • Fixed: The parsed pageMode variable is now properly used and sent to the service as a string
  • Location: Controllers/DotCmsUVEController.cs line 53

2. ✅ Missing Null Check for Path Parameter

  • Fixed: Added validation for catchAll parameter, defaulting to "/" if null or empty
  • Location: Controllers/DotCmsUVEController.cs lines 39-43

3. ✅ Resource Leak in ContentletExample Method

  • Fixed: Removed the problematic Clone() method usage that was causing resource leaks
  • Location: Controllers/DotCmsUVEController.cs lines 94-111

4. ✅ Inconsistent Error Handling

  • Fixed: Replaced raw exception messages with generic error messages to avoid exposing sensitive information
  • Location: Controllers/DotCmsUVEController.cs lines 73-76 and 119-122

5. ✅ Missing Path Validation in Service

  • Fixed: Added path traversal attack prevention in NormalizePath method
  • Location: Services/DotCmsService.cs lines 424-428

6. ✅ Missing Validation for Depth Parameter

  • Fixed: Added validation to ensure depth is non-negative and warn if exceeds recommended maximum
  • Location: Services/DotCmsService.cs lines 163-171

7. ✅ Inefficient String Concatenation in Logging

  • Fixed: Replaced string interpolation with structured logging for better performance
  • Location: Controllers/DotCmsUVEController.cs lines 35, 50-52, 81

8. ✅ GraphQL Query Injection Risk

  • Fixed: Added EscapeGraphqlString method to properly escape user input in GraphQL queries
  • Location: Services/DotCmsService.cs lines 383-415 and 417-432

Additional Improvements Made

  1. Security Enhancement: Path traversal patterns are now blocked
  2. Performance: Structured logging improves log processing efficiency
  3. Reliability: Better error handling prevents information leakage
  4. Code Quality: More consistent and maintainable code structure

Remaining Recommendations

While we've fixed the critical bugs, here are some additional improvements that could be made:

  1. Add Unit Tests: Create comprehensive unit tests for all the fixed scenarios
  2. Implement Rate Limiting: Add rate limiting to prevent API abuse
  3. Add Request Timeouts: Configure appropriate timeouts for HTTP requests
  4. Use IOptions Pattern: For strongly-typed configuration
  5. Implement Circuit Breaker: For resilience when calling external APIs
  6. Create Custom Exception Types: For better error handling and logging
  7. Add API Documentation: Document all public methods with XML comments
  8. Implement Health Checks: Add health check endpoints for monitoring

Testing Recommendations

To verify these fixes:

  1. Test with null/empty paths
  2. Test with path traversal attempts (e.g., "../etc/passwd")
  3. Test with GraphQL injection attempts (e.g., quotes in parameters)
  4. Test with negative depth values
  5. Test error scenarios to ensure no sensitive information is exposed
  6. Monitor logs to verify structured logging is working correctly

wezell added 2 commits June 23, 2025 19:05
### 1. ✅ **Unused Variable in DotCmsUVEController**
- **Fixed**: The parsed `pageMode` variable is now properly used and sent to the service as a string
- **Location**: `Controllers/DotCmsUVEController.cs` line 53

### 2. ✅ **Missing Null Check for Path Parameter**
- **Fixed**: Added validation for `catchAll` parameter, defaulting to "/" if null or empty
- **Location**: `Controllers/DotCmsUVEController.cs` lines 39-43

### 3. ✅ **Resource Leak in ContentletExample Method**
- **Fixed**: Removed the problematic `Clone()` method usage that was causing resource leaks
- **Location**: `Controllers/DotCmsUVEController.cs` lines 94-111

### 4. ✅ **Inconsistent Error Handling**
- **Fixed**: Replaced raw exception messages with generic error messages to avoid exposing sensitive information
- **Location**: `Controllers/DotCmsUVEController.cs` lines 73-76 and 119-122

### 5. ✅ **Missing Path Validation in Service**
- **Fixed**: Added path traversal attack prevention in `NormalizePath` method
- **Location**: `Services/DotCmsService.cs` lines 424-428

### 6. ✅ **Missing Validation for Depth Parameter**
- **Fixed**: Added validation to ensure depth is non-negative and warn if exceeds recommended maximum
- **Location**: `Services/DotCmsService.cs` lines 163-171

### 7. ✅ **Inefficient String Concatenation in Logging**
- **Fixed**: Replaced string interpolation with structured logging for better performance
- **Location**: `Controllers/DotCmsUVEController.cs` lines 35, 50-52, 81

### 8. ✅ **GraphQL Query Injection Risk**
- **Fixed**: Added `EscapeGraphqlString` method to properly escape user input in GraphQL queries
- **Location**: `Services/DotCmsService.cs` lines 383-415 and 417-432

## Additional Improvements Made

1. **Security Enhancement**: Path traversal patterns are now blocked
2. **Performance**: Structured logging improves log processing efficiency
3. **Reliability**: Better error handling prevents information leakage
4. **Code Quality**: More consistent and maintainable code structure
@wezell wezell merged commit 2a6f601 into main Jun 24, 2025
1 check failed
@wezell wezell deleted the jorge-demo branch June 24, 2025 02:19
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant