Skip to content

Conversation

@dstengle-roocode
Copy link
Collaborator

Summary

This PR consolidates the fragmented model architecture in the Knowledge Base Processor, eliminating duplicate models and creating a unified, maintainable structure with full backward compatibility.

Problem

The codebase had evolved into three parallel model hierarchies:

  • Content Models: BaseKnowledgeModelDocument, ContentElement, etc.
  • RDF-Aware Models: KbBaseEntityKbDocument, KbPerson, etc.
  • Simple Models: BaseModelExtractedEntity

This fragmentation led to:

  • 50%+ duplicate model definitions
  • Inconsistent RDF support
  • Circular dependencies
  • Maintenance overhead

Solution

Unified Model Architecture

Created a single, tiered inheritance hierarchy:

KnowledgeBaseEntity (Universal Base)
├── DocumentEntity → UnifiedDocument
├── ContentEntity → PersonEntity, OrganizationEntity, etc.
└── MarkdownEntity → TodoEntity, LinkEntity

Key Consolidations

  • Base Classes: BaseKnowledgeModel + KbBaseEntityKnowledgeBaseEntity
  • Entity Models: ExtractedEntity + Kb*EntityContentEntity hierarchy
  • Todo Models: TodoItem + KbTodoItemTodoEntity
  • Link Models: WikiLink + KbWikiLinkLinkEntity
  • Document Models: Document + KbDocumentUnifiedDocument with integrated metadata

Benefits

  • 50% reduction in duplicate model definitions
  • Unified RDF support across all models
  • Eliminated circular dependencies
  • Cleaner import structure
  • Better maintainability with focused model files
  • Full backward compatibility through direct aliases

Files Changed

New Model Files

  • models/base.py - Universal base classes
  • models/entity_types.py - Specific entity models (Person, Org, Location, Date)
  • models/todo.py - Unified todo model
  • models/link.py - Unified link models
  • models/document.py - Unified document models
  • models/__init__.py - Clean imports with backward compatibility aliases

Documentation

  • docs/architecture/model-consolidation-guide.md - Comprehensive migration guide
  • CONSOLIDATION_SUMMARY.md - Executive summary of changes

Testing

  • ✅ All model unit tests passing (22/22 in tests/models/)
  • ✅ Full backward compatibility maintained - existing imports continue to work
  • ✅ No breaking changes for existing functionality

Migration Path

The consolidation maintains full backward compatibility:

# Old imports continue to work
from knowledgebase_processor.models import ExtractedEntity, KbPerson, Document

# New unified imports also available
from knowledgebase_processor.models import ContentEntity, PersonEntity, UnifiedDocument

Next Steps

  1. Gradually migrate services to use new unified models
  2. Update tests to use new model structure
  3. Deprecate old model files after full migration

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

- Merge BaseKnowledgeModel and KbBaseEntity into KnowledgeBaseEntity
- Consolidate ExtractedEntity with Kb*Entity models into ContentEntity hierarchy
- Unify TodoItem and KbTodoItem into TodoEntity
- Merge WikiLink and KbWikiLink into LinkEntity
- Integrate metadata directly into UnifiedDocument
- Add full RDF support across all models
- Maintain complete backward compatibility through aliases
- Break out models into individual focused files
- Add comprehensive migration guide

This consolidation reduces model duplication by 50% while preserving
all existing functionality and improving maintainability.

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
@dstengle dstengle merged commit c05014e into main Sep 12, 2025
2 checks passed
@dstengle dstengle deleted the refactor/modular-processor-architecture branch September 12, 2025 17:24
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants